Investing with Purpose - Articles for Financial Decision Making

The Advantages of Purchasing Individual Bonds or CDs vs. Bond Funds

Written by Kyle J. McCauley APMA®, CRPC® | Jul 12, 2023 8:36:18 PM

Investors are always on the lookout for the most efficient and safe methods to diversify their portfolios. Among the investment options available, bonds, whether individual or part of a fund, stand as attractive choices due to their relative safety compared to equity investments. However, a closer look reveals noteworthy benefits in opting for individual bonds or certificates of deposit (CDs) over bond funds, particularly concerning interest rate risk, income timing, and risk control.

Minimizing Interest Rate Risk

A prominent advantage of purchasing individual bonds or CDs as opposed to bond funds is the minimized exposure to interest rate risk. Bond prices and interest rates have an inverse relationship – as interest rates rise, bond prices fall, and vice versa. Therefore, the value of bond funds can fluctuate with changes in the interest rates, posing a significant risk to investors.

However, with individual bonds, as long as the bond doesn't default, you get back the full face value at maturity, regardless of what happens to interest rates. CDs, too, bear this feature, promising a specific return at the end of the term regardless of interest rate fluctuations.

Controlling Timing of Income, Interest, and Maturities

Individual bonds and CDs allow investors to control the timing of their income streams more effectively than bond funds. The interest payment and maturity dates of these investments are preset, allowing for precise cash flow planning. Bond funds, on the other hand, have fluctuating dividends, and there is no set maturity date, making cash flow timing less predictable.

Transparency of Fees and Costs

Individual bonds and CDs also offer greater transparency regarding fees and costs. When purchasing these investment products, transaction costs, including the broker’s commission, are upfront and clear. Conversely, bond funds can have hidden fees, such as management, marketing, distribution, and other operating costs, that are drawn from the fund's assets. This lack of transparency can make it harder for investors to calculate the real cost of the investment.

Risk Control

In terms of risk control, buying individual bonds or CDs gives investors the chance to scrutinize the specific risk associated with each bond or issuer. This approach is contrasting to bond funds, which might hold a rating of 'A' but can carry bonds rated as 'BB' or even unrated bonds, thereby adding to the portfolio's risk profile.

Counterbalance: Risks of Owning Individual Bonds

However, investing in individual bonds or CDs does come with its own set of risks. They may lack the diversification benefit that bond funds provide, which spreads risk across various bonds from different issuers. Moreover, the market for individual bonds can sometimes be less liquid than for bond funds, making it harder for investors to sell their bonds if needed.

Mitigating Risks

Despite these potential pitfalls, careful selection of specific bonds and strategic portfolio construction can help mitigate risks. By focusing on true guarantees like CDs and secured bonds over unsecured bonds, investors can have a better assurance of return. Secured bonds, backed by collateral, provide a safety net in case the issuer defaults.

In conclusion, while bond funds can offer convenience and diversification, the benefits of purchasing individual bonds or CDs—such as minimizing interest rate risk, controlling income timing, and better risk management—often make them a more attractive choice for savvy investors. A well-researched and meticulously constructed bond portfolio can offer significant advantages in terms of return predictability, cost transparency, and overall risk management.