Investing with Purpose - Articles for Financial Decision Making

Build Your Own Fixed Indexed Annuity without the Annuity

Written by Kyle J. McCauley APMA®, CRPC® | Oct 5, 2023 2:28:15 PM

In the quest for balanced financial growth, Fixed Indexed Annuities (FIAs) have emerged as a sought-after tool. Their allure? The duality of safeguarding principal while capturing a slice of stock market gains. Traditional annuities are typically the domain of insurance companies. However, for the astute investor, there’s potential to emulate the structure of a FIA with a bespoke blend of fixed income assets and options.

The Essence of a Fixed Indexed Annuity

Before diving deep into constructing one, it’s vital to grasp the core essence of a FIA. At its heart, a FIA marries the protective shield of fixed income assets with the tantalizing growth prospects of the stock market. Should the market surge, the investor enjoys a percentage of that growth. But when the market falters, the principal remains untouched. This safety net, combined with potential upside, is what makes FIAs enticing.

1. Establishing a Solid Foundation with Fixed Income Assets

The bedrock of a FIA is the assurance that the principal is secure. Emulating this requires an emphasis on stability. Instruments like Certificates of Deposit (CDs), US Treasuries, and top-tier investment-grade bonds are prime candidates.

  • Certificates of Deposit (CDs): These are time-specific deposits made with banks that promise a set interest rate. Their risk is minimal as they are FDIC insured up to a limit.
  • US Treasuries: Among the safest investments, these government-backed securities offer varying maturities, from a few days to 30 years. They're backed by the full faith and credit of the US government.
  • Investment-Grade Bonds: Bonds from reputable institutions with high credit ratings fall under this category. While they offer a lower yield compared to their high-yield counterparts, their risk is considerably diminished.

A diversified portfolio of these assets ensures a regular stream of income with the peace of mind that the principal amount remains largely insulated from market volatilities.

2. Harnessing the Stock Market's Potential through Options

With the safety net in place, the next step is to dip into the stock market’s potential. But how can one venture into this volatile territory without jeopardizing their principal? The answer lies in options.

Using the proceeds or yield from the fixed income portfolio, an investor can purchase call options on a basket of stocks or an Exchange Traded Fund (ETF). These options are essentially a bet on the future price of stocks or ETFs. If the stocks or ETFs appreciate beyond a certain price (the strike price), the investor stands to gain. If not, the loss is limited to the premium paid for the option.

This strategy allows for a calculated risk. The principal remains secure in fixed assets, while the yield, which would have been a modest income, now has the potential for exponential growth.

3. Decoding the Participation Rate

In traditional FIAs, the insurance company determines how much of the market's growth an investor is entitled to, termed as the 'participation rate'. In our self-crafted FIA, this rate becomes a function of our investment decisions.

Participation Rate= (Number of options bought × Strike Price × 100) / Initial Investment

This formula indicates how much of the stock market's upside the investor can benefit from, considering the number of options they've managed to buy and the sensitivity of the option's price to the underlying asset (delta).

Illustrative Example:

Imagine an investor with a principal of $1,000,000. With a net of fee yield of 5.5% from fixed income assets, they amass an annual yield of $55,000.

Given the current SPY price at $422 and the Strike Price of $422 and each option's cost at $40, our investor can acquire 13 Options.

Participation Rate = (13 x $422 X 100) / $1,000,000

Thus, this savvy investor would relish 54.86% of any upward movements in SPY over the forthcoming year.

In Retrospect:

Crafting a personalized fixed indexed annuity is an endeavor that offers both control and flexibility. It's a method to potentially magnify returns while maintaining a safety cushion. However, while the benefits are promising, the complexities involved necessitate a comprehensive understanding. Investors are encouraged to seek guidance from financial professionals to navigate this.